Pdf marxs theory of the money commodity researchgate. Marxs theory of money is therefore in the first place a commodity theory of money. Kuruma carefully explains each of the theoretical questions raised by marx. And the main content includes the following aspects. Pdf marxs theory of the money commodity anitra nelson. This feature should recommend the study of his theory of money to modern stu dents of monetary problems. Murray, patrick 1988, marxs theory of scientific knowledge.
Karl marxs theory of money and credit, chapters, in. Jun 21, 2017 marx s view of value transforms into a labor theory on value because he claims people naturally assign value based on how hard they worked to produce the product. Jul 12, 2005 marx s value theory is often presented as a simple costs of production theory, where we add up labour valueadded in the various stages of production to come up with a final value. In this volume, marxs theory of the g enesis of money. He used the change from feudal society run by the noblemen, clergy, and commoners and based upon heredity. Marxs theory of money is inextricably linked to his labor theory of value and cannot be treated or understood in separation. Marxs ambivalence towards classical political economy 5 social capital and the general rate of profit 111. Marxs theory of the genesis of money how, why, and through. This work shows that the theory of money is an indispensable part of marxs theory of value, and among the most original aspects of marxs economics. It developed from a political critique of the utopian socialists concepts of money, labour time and exchange value.
Why marx neither has nor needs a commodity theory of money. Marxs theory of money and the theory of value essay. He uses the term entfremdung estrangement which is his alienation theory. I was even inclined towards the view that many of the criticisms levelled against marxs theory of price, particularly those emanating from the sraf. The critique by credit theorists of marx s monetary theory has long been challenged on different grounds. It is a major concept in karl marx s critique of political economy. It seems that marx believed that redefining labourtime as abstract labour and socially necessary labourtime meant that his money commodity could directly represent value without necessarily also implying. But marxs theory of money is clearly a commodity theory of money. Marx s theory of money and the theory of value the most important point to emerge from marx s theory of money is the idea that money is a form of value. For ingham, marx has little to say on credit money. However, from the moment of marxs death, it had already become apparent that marxist theory and marxist economic analysis would. The socioeconomic basis of money cannot be suspended by tampering with interest rates i. What are the key ways that simmels discussion of value.
The theory of labourvalue is the starting point, but not the only one, for criticizing the quantity theory of money. The third part focuses on marxs theory of the money commodity. In the former, he demonstrated that it was possible, on the basis of the contemporary data, to reconstitute the whole economic system of karl marx 100 years after the first publication of marxs capital. It developed from a political critique of the utopian socialists concepts of money. Dec 02, 2019 the main content and contribution of marxs monetary theory. Thus marx adopted a labour theory of value, as had his predecessors ricardo and macculloch. A first cut at marxs value theory, i conclude, centers on the constantly shifting and contradictory unity between what is traditionally referred to as the labour theory of value in the sphere of the market as set out in the first six chapters of capital and the value theory of labour in the sphere of production as. Otherwise it is difficult to understand marx s criticism of ricardos theory of money and to introduce the fiat money. He was opposed to nominalist theories of money in general. The problem of consciousness, social structure and the use of force 4. Marxs theory of money and 21stcentury macrodynamics levy.
Part i marxs basic theory of money 1 the commodity nature of money in marxs theory 21 claus germer 2 marxs theory of money in historical perspective 36 duncan foley 3 money as displaced social form. As marx notes in the letter, the bourgeoisie need hardly bother with the concept of value. Marxs theory of money in historical perspective mount holyoke. No less an authority on economic doctrine than joseph schumpeter. Specific topics of concern include 1 todays identity of the money commodity, 2 possible heterogeneity of the money commodity, 3 the categories.
Jan 20, 2017 on the other hand, marx s theory of money has also been severely criticized, especially that it seems to require that money be a produced commodity. This is demonstrated by reference to marx s account of the social functions of money, and by showing that to subsume money under commodity commits a category mistake within marx s system. Money may be a mirror in which the value of a commodity is reflected, but. The theory of value and the theory of money in marxs theory of capitalist economy 11 i relation between the theory of essays on value and the theory of.
There is also marxism as it has been understood and practiced by the various socialist movements, particularly before 1914. According to marx s theory, surplus value is equal to the new value created by workers in excess of their own laborcost, which is appropriated by the capitalist as profit when products are sold. Conventionally, valueadded is equal to the sum of gross wage income and gross profit income. Marx s intellectual debt to, and distinction from, the german philosopher hegel are more complicated. And in the third section, based on what we have from the reexamination of marxs general money theory, i demonstrate the endogeneity of non.
If it is true that money arose first in history as a unit of account for taxes and debt payments as chartalists argue, that. Marxs theory of the genesis of money how, why, and. Marxism is a social, political, and economic theory originated by karl marx, which focuses on the struggle between capitalists and the working class. According to the standard interpretation of the transformation problem in marxs theory, the money commodity e. What matters here is following the process of marx s thought, rather than stopping at the valueof money problem. Marxs money theory is a general theory that can coherently explain both commodity money regime and noncommodity money regime, and that the state is an important factor in marxs general money theory. If it were shown, for example, that the theory of alienation was only temporarily held by marx, this in itself would be no obstacle to accepting it. The difficulty with this idea is that we are more familiar with money itself than with value in other forms. He intended it to be a sound materialist theory of money. Marxs theory of money in historical perspective springerlink. Theory of value and ideology 4 the question of commodity fetishism 67 part iii. Marxs theory of money and the transformation problem.
Statecredit moneys are analyzed through marxs concept of fictitious capital, leading to a critique of the neoclassical view of the value of money. The theory of value and the theory of money in marxs theory of capitalist economy 11 i relation between the theory of essays on value and the theory of essays on money 12 ii particular theoretical framework of the beginning of capital. Why value cannot be independent of price 50 patrick murray 4 marxs objections to credit theories of money 65 anitra nelson. This is significant because recent attention to marxs concept of money includes sympathetic revisions and reconstructions substituting marxian credit theories of money for marxs theory of the money commodity. Some strengths in marxs disequilibrium theory of money oxford. The object and method of marxs capital marxs capital does not present an analysis of different economic models of themes. In parallel, the paper presents a brief synthesis of marxist state theory and suggests that state money could be read through marxs critique of political economy. It is the consequence of viewing the world in an erroneous way. Marx s theory of money is considered to be more acceptable base for more concrete research on money than neoclassical money theory, as far as the last one meet serious theoretical difficulties in explanation of the nature of money.
Marxs theory of money also provides important quantitative conclusions regarding the price of commodities and the quantity of money in circulation. And on the contrary, even if it were theory held permanently by marx, we may find that there are defects in it. Marxs theory of money and the transformation problem by fred moseley. Primitive communism is a way of describing the gift economies of huntergatherers throughout history, where resources and property hunted and gathered are shared with all members of a group, in accordance with individual needs. The contributors to the volume provide a wideranging and indepth appraisal of the strengths and weaknesses of marx s theory of money, compared to other theories of money. This is marxs general theory of capitalist crisis, of which his theory of money is an essential part. Major changes according to marx are a result of new forces of production. Foley, on marxs theory of money, social concept 11, 519, 1983 the money form of value will also be present. Marxs developing economic views were given expression in a polemic.
Keynesian economic theory keynesian economic theory keynesian economic theory is an economic school of thought that broadly states that government intervention is needed to help economies emerge marxian economics marxian economics marxian economics refers tp a school of economic thought that was derived from karl marx and friedrich engels, who. The function of money as expressing labor time is common to all commodityproducing societies, but different arrangements perform this function in each society. If the first place, it is assumed that the money commodity has a valueprice price proportional to labourtime 2 and also has a price of production. Foley from the point of view of later heterodox economics, three features of marxs theory are particularly important. Marxs monetary theory and its practical value emerald insight. Some strengths in marxs disequilibrium theory of money. In both cases, it is capitals own expansion that then causes it to run into the barriers it has set itself. Marx demonstrated that the classical economists category of value is nothing but objecti.
In this way, marx s monetary theory seems to be able to make understandable the current capitalist money, which takes the form of state paper money and purchasing power privately created by the. Nonetheless the significance of marx s theory of a money commodity clearly stands out precisely in this context, for it is only that his money is a commodity and product of labour that seems to save it from the pure idealism with which he charges the utopian socialists and hegel. A given commodity can play the role of universal medium of exchange, as well as fulfil all the other functions of money, precisely because it is a commodity, i. According to a recent report from the engineering employers association in the united. Marxs theory of money is a window on to what is most distinctive.
Historians of economic thought challenge the lineage of commodity theories based on marx s. In political sociology and anthropology, it is also a concept often credited to karl marx and friedrich engels for originating, who wrote that huntergatherer societies. It seeks to locate, not to deny, the role of gold in marx s monetary theory. It makes no difference to the argument, and it may secure a better hearing for marx, if we say he means that the value of money is measured by its. Marxs monetary theory and its practical value emerald. Marxs objections to credit theories of money anitra nelson marx criticised credit theories of money with which he was familiar. Endogeneity of money and the state in marxs theory of non. Foley, on marx s theory of money, social concept 11, 519, 1983 money allows us to recognize marx s theory in the reality we experience. His theory of the money commodity is a unique commodity theory of money. This is clear today, where money is predominantly not coins, but cash and credit. Marxian economics emerged from marxs earlier historicsociological analyses and is formulated along with a new methodological approach.
On the other hand, marx s theory of money has also been severely criticized, especially that it seems to require that money be a produced commodity. So marx s theory of money developed out of a critique of the utopian socialists concepts of money, labourtime and exchangevalue and it had definite political implications. Marx s term is the german word mehrwert, which simply means value added sales revenue less the cost of materials used up, and is cognate to english more worth. Marxism, a body of doctrine developed by karl marx and, to a lesser extent, by friedrich engels in the mid19th century. It begins primarily as a money commodity, such as the precious metals, with a value of its own, but later develops to be a mere symbol of value.
Marx formulated after 1857 a new labour theory of value. More recently serious challenges to marxs theory of money have appeared, along with reinterpretations, and even extensive revisions such as the neomarxian credit theories of foley 1982 and lipietz 1983. Unlike theorists who become preoccupied with particular functions and forms of money, marx develops a comprehensive concept of money. Marxs theory of money is critiqued relative to the advent of fiat and electronic currencies and the development of financial markets.
Karl marxs theory of alienation alienation is a purely intellectual phenomenon for hegel and feuerbach. The main content and contribution of marxs monetary theory. Marx s views is possible, it cannot settle the question of the value of these views. Hence, marx s use of mehrwert has always been translated as surplus value, distinguishing it from valueadded. Karl marx overview, marxism and behavioral economics. Marx believed that money performs five functions, namely, measure value, means of circulation, means of hoarding, means. It developed from a political critique of the utopian socialists concepts of. After being largely neglected by marxist scholars in the first twothirds of the twentieth century, with some exceptions such as rubin 1972, marxs theory of money has been the subject of a substantial number of books and articles in the last 35 years.
Pdf marxs critique of ricardian political economy, the. Therefore, in marx, the genesis of money is not historical, but rather conceptual. It is a historically specific theory, not a general theory of money throughout history, nor a theory of money in precapitalist economies. Actually adam smiths value theory was one where he tried to assess the contribution of each factor of production to the value of the final product.
Part i marx versus ricardo the marxian theory of value. The second part identifies credit theories of money familiar to marx and discusses his objections to them. Marxs theory of the money commodity anitra nelson abstract marx defines the commodity in a unique way. Marx s theory of alienation considers the human and social implications of the abstraction and commercialization of labour. Gold is a commodity like all other commodities, and at the same time.
559 837 1018 841 372 1533 1068 405 599 1074 1163 687 813 1421 1358 855 1067 711 928 332 1512 1071 291 491 25 1087 1459 652 355 1552 615 898 33 1224 588 740 1359 966 998